[RUSH TRANSCRIPT BELOW]For decades, public health officials have promoted industrial seed oils—corn, canola, soybean, and sunflower, to name a few—as healthy replacements for traditional animal fats. Dr. Cate Shanahan, a family physician and author of “Dark Calories” and “Deep Nutrition,” believes the opposite.
Dr. Shanahan argues that these oils are uniquely toxic and the primary drivers of modern metabolic and neurological disease.
Seed oils are the “number one source of brain-damaging calories in our food supply,” she says.
She unpacks how these oils generate toxic aldehydes when processed and heated. She reveals how the post-2000 trans-fat ban inadvertently made fried foods more unhealthy. And she examines the correlation between the dramatic rise in seed oil consumption and the near doubling of obesity rates.
She answers some important questions.
Do seed oils lead to mitochondrial dysfunction? Has mainstream nutrition science largely ignored seed oil risks? And what steps can people take to remove seed oils and restore traditional fats to their diets?
Views expressed in this video are opinions of the host and the guest and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
RUSH TRANSCRIPT
Jan Jekielek:
Dr. Cate Shanahan, such a pleasure to have you on American Thought Leaders.
Dr. Cate Shanahan:
Jan, it is such a pleasure to be here with you, finally.
Mr. Jekielek:
Well, finally is right. You’ve compiled an incredibly important body of work. And one of the most startling things that I’ve come across, right, is that you’re saying these seed oils, these processed seed oils, are actually brain killers. And I want you to just justify that to me because that is a bold statement.
Dr. Shanahan:
It’s actually an entire chapter, a 50-page chapter, in this book called Deep Nutrition, which I call Brain Killer: Seven Strategies that Seed Oils Use to Disrupt Brain Function. A lot of it comes down to the simple fact that our brain generates a lot of energy. It needs a lot of oxygen, and it generates a lot of energy. It needs energy to sustain its electrical grid, right?
So, our brain is only 2 per cent of our body weight, but it is generating 20 per cent of the energy in our body. You could also say that it’s burning 20 per cent of the calories that we’re burning. Those are two sides of the same exact concept. And so, to generate energy, every cell in our body uses these little biological machines called mitochondria. They use oxygen to transform our food into cellular energy.
Whether or not they can do that efficiently has to do with our food. And one of the things that seed oils do that is harmful, and that very few people in medical research appreciate, is that the fatty acids in seed oils are a very poor source of fuel for mitochondrial energy generation. And what happens when you kind of force-feed these oils, seed oils, to your mitochondria is that instead of getting efficient energy generation, they kind of heat up a little too much. It’s kind of like putting the wrong kind of fuel in your car. The engine could run hot, you get a lot of smog and pollution. That’s exactly what happens inside the cell.
Then, of course, a brain cell experiencing that isn’t going to function as well. And it’s going to end up with potentially some cellular damage. It could lead to inflammation. So, this is the beginning of how we get many, many diseases of the brain that affect us throughout our entire lifespan. So, it doesn’t matter if you’re young or old, these oils are going to be affecting how well your brain can do its job.
I’ve just recently published a paper on how the aldehydes in cooking oils, the seed oils, are possibly responsible for a good portion of the brain malformations that we see in developmental disorders that include autism, but pretty much any brain developmental disorder. We could be talking about whether a person gets dyslexia or other learning disorders or sensory processing disorders. That’s how it affects us early in life. That’s how these seed oils kill our brain early in life.
In middle life, we can get diseases like anxiety, depression, mood disorders, learning disorders.And then in later life, we can end up with early-onset memory problems like dementia, Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s.The conversation around all of these diseases, I think, needs to center on seed oils and starting to look at the literature that has been produced over the past several decades that shows a potential link. And I’m starting to publish literature that puts it together. So, we’re starting to get some of these things published now.
Mr. Jekielek:
And, you know, I’ve, of course, I’ve been very familiar with the health freedom movement over the last few years, you know, what now is called MAHA [Make America Healthy Again], as well. And seed oils are one of the things that is talked about often, and the removal of seed oils and bringing back things like beef tallow, for example. You’re advocating for a return to these types of fats? Is that it?
Dr. Shanahan:
Absolutely, because there was nothing wrong with them. There was no reason other than basically medical misinformation, or you could say maybe misunderstanding, and commercial misinformation. Changes in the food supply, in the food chain. That was the main reason that we changed, that we moved away from them.
Two things happened at the same time. We changed, you know, how we fed our animals, and it produced a lot of byproducts, like soy feed, right? We created a lot of these oils. So suddenly we had all these oils, we didn’t know what to do with them. Well, they wanted to sell them to people. People didn’t like them.
So, what happened was they found a way to make people buy them, and that’s really important. It was kind of a dark period in our nutritional history. That’s why I call the book Dark Calories, one of the reasons. There was nothing wrong with these oils. And we’ve kind of, medical science has been living under the delusion that heart disease and cardiovascular diseases are caused by these ancient fats that people have consumed throughout time immemorial, without developing metabolic problems or heart attacks.
Mr. Jekielek:
Give me a picture of the scale of use of these eight seed oils that you identify because they’re not apparent. Like in many cases, these things are used in things that we consume where it’s not obvious that there’s an oil involved necessarily. Can you sort of unpack that for me?
Dr. Shanahan:
Today, the average American is getting somewhere between 60 and 80 per cent of their total fat calories from these seed oils. It’s a collection of eight seed oils that once you start looking for them, you’re going to see them everywhere; corn, canola, cottonseed, soy, sunflower, safflower, rice bran, and grapeseed. So, that 60 to 80 per cent of our fat calories equates to somewhere between 400 and 600 calories per person per day, which is huge. Depending on how you look at the data, these may be the greatest single source of calories in the entire food supply, greater than sugar, greater than flour. It depends a little bit on your diet, but for some people, they are.
How many were we eating, like 50 years ago, when they had just started coming into the food supply? It was a little sort of trickling in at the beginning of the century, kind of increasing very slightly until World War II. After World War II, they exploded from pretty much nothing to maybe about 10 to 15 percent of our fat calories. Then just over the past, over the rest of the 20th century, and now into the 21st century, the line just goes up and to the right, as they say.
We’ve just increased and increased, pretty much year over year, especially in the past 20 years or so. We’ve pretty much doubled in just that time. So that is the scale. People are eating these things in massive quantities and have no idea that they’re doing it or that they’re harmful. And frankly, medical science really doesn’t either.
When you ask me about, like, what is the scale? It was quite a struggle, I have to tell you, to figure out how much we’re actually eating because the government doesn’t keep good data on this anymore. I had to use statistica.com and do all kinds of additions and subtractions and calculations by myself, which could have been an independently published paper as it was, but that was just to create the first figure in dark calories to get a handle on what we’re eating now and what we’ve been eating.
Mr. Jekielek:
So, this is a very, very significant portion of our diet, which is, first of all, astonishing. Second of all, what is the mechanism? You’re saying these things are toxic at some level, at different levels. And I understand that they’re not, that they become more toxic over time as they’re incorporated and reincorporated into the food system as food gets more and more processed. Could you unpack that for me, please?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, so it’s really important to understand that the way seed oils are toxic is unique in the food supply. Normally, when we think about a toxin, we think about something that was blown in on the wind, you know, like glyphosates, or was in the soil and is present at a certain amount because it was added knowingly and we can measure it. That amount stays constant or may even diminish as you go through the processing. It might get washed off. So, that is a very important concept in toxicology because we need to measure a toxin to understand what it could be doing to us.
But when it comes to the seed oils, it’s very difficult to measure. First of all, the equipment is very expensive and complicated because these molecules are so very reactive. They’re different from things like mercury and lead and glyphosate. They’re more reactive, they appear and then they can disappear. And when they disappear, they do bad things to us. So just measuring them is difficult.
The other thing that makes them unique is that where is the toxicity coming from? Well, like I said, it’s not being added. It’s not the environment. It’s coming from the chemistry within the oil itself, because the oil itself is uniquely unstable. And when I say unstable, I mean that it’s not going to stay what nature made, right?
So, in a seed, like a soybean or a sunflower, we have two kinds of fatty acids that are very unstable.They’re polyunsaturated fatty acids. One’s called linoleic, one’s called alpha linoleic. One’s an omega-6, if you’re interested in the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, one’s an omega-3. That part doesn’t matter. Both of them are very changeable, and that’s the problem.
Both of them are unstable. They will react with oxygen once they’re removed from the seed. See, inside the seed, they’re protected. They’re protected because the seed itself is a solid barrier keeping oxygen out. They’re also protected by antioxidants and vitamins like vitamin E.
In the factories, we take out these oils and expose them to oxygen, lots of oxygen. They start to break down into toxins. It’s through that that the toxins develop. The toxins aren’t added. They develop by exposure to oxygen and exposure to heat.
That’s another thing that makes it very complicated because you could take a look at these oils at different time points in the production chain and see different amounts of toxins. If you are somebody who says, I want to see what the worst case scenario is and study that. Then you’re going to look at a deep fried french fry. Or if you want to see how they start out life, then you'll look at oil as it’s coming out of the factory.
When people have done this, they see that the amount of these toxins, which are, there’s many, many of them too, further complicates the issue. But the most well studied are called aldehydes. When people study the aldehydes, there’s trace amounts when they come out of the factory. There’s none in fats like coconut oil or olive oil. So, the chemistry does matter. But as you go up the food chain, as there’s more heat and more light and more exposure to air, you get more and more toxin formation.
And by the end, when we’re talking about something that’s really bad, like a French fry from a fast food restaurant where they leave the oil being heated for hours, days, sometimes weeks, then the amount of these toxic aldehydes is, it’s so extreme that it’s, you know, one of the scientists named Martin Grootveld discovered that it’s pretty much the same as what you get from smoking an entire pack of cigarettes when you eat a large serving of fries.
Mr. Jekielek:
And how does one calculate that? How do you calculate the health cost of smoking a pack of cigarettes vs. the health cost of eating a deep-fried French fry out of a vat of seed oil that’s been there for weeks?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, wouldn’t it be nice if we just had a calculator we could plug this into. But the thing is, these are thought experiments, and they need to be done by scientists, and they need to be published so that we can talk about them and say, is this accurate? And then these thought experiments need to be tested. That hasn’t happened.
None of that has happened because, well, all the researchers I’ve spoken to in this area just say they have such a hard time getting funding. They have a hard time getting funding because largely the ideology is that these oils are healthy. Why are we looking for their health harms? We’ve got so much supposed data that shows that they’re healthy. The question’s already been settled. Why waste money? That’s part of the current culture.
So, I’ve run my own thought experiments, and I would say that seed oils are actually worse than cigarettes for two big reasons. One, you know, nobody gives a two-year-old a pack of cigarettes, but we very often do feed two-year-olds French fries from fast food. I’m not shaming parents. But I’m saying you should know this, and you’re not going to hear it in the doctor’s office or the pediatrician’s office.
Secondly, there’s a whole other type of toxicity. So, seed oils are truly one-of-a-kind toxins. Not only do they have these moving targets of the aldehydes that we were talking about, but they can also build up in our body fat in ways that we haven’t talked about yet. And I have an entire book that discusses the consequences of that. It’s called The Fatburn Fix.
This book says that when we’ve been eating seed oils, it essentially makes our body fat unpalatable to our cells, and our cells really don’t want to burn our body fat. They don’t want to burn the main fuel that nature created for us to have between meals so we don’t get hungry. What does that do? Well, it makes us metabolically unwell.
What does that mean? It gives us diabetes. It gives us insulin resistance, the precursor to diabetes. It gives us, a lot of us, a tendency to overeat. So, understanding the vast array of how seed oils harm us really gives us a lot of answers. Cigarette smoking doesn’t make anybody gain weight, but seed oil consumption, I believe, does. I believe it’s driving the obesity epidemic. And smoking causes a lot of inflammatory disease and degenerative disease and lots of cancers.
But we don’t build babies’ brains out of cigarettes, but we do build babies’ brains out of the oils and seed oils. We build babies’ bodies, and babies’ bodies are being built differently. I truly believe that this altered chemical construction of humanity, thanks largely to seed oils, is something we need to stop overlooking and start digging into and understanding the real consequences of this decision made mostly by the American Heart Association to promote these oils as heart-healthy.
Mr. Jekielek:
One of the things I’ve come to understand is that drinking giant sugary drinks of simple carbohydrates is one of the drivers of obesity. It’s kind of obvious. The mechanism there is kind of obvious. You’re just consuming insane amounts of empty calories, right? And of course, those get reflected in fat and so forth. So, that one is easy to grasp. Is seed oil a bigger contributor or a lesser contributor? Or does an interactive effect make things twice as bad? Which is the case?
Dr. Shanahan:
Seed oils are a bigger contributor. Now, it took me a couple of years to sort this out. When I first wrote the first edition of Deep Nutrition, I was like, well, they’re both really bad. But then I realized that seed oils have to be worse, and we actually do now have some data to support this observational data.
What happened between the years 2000 and today in terms of our consumption of seed oils vs. sugar and vis-a-vis obesity. Between the year 2000 and 2020, we actually have data on three important things. We have data on seed oil consumption. I had to put it together. Our seed oil consumption pretty close to doubled during those 20 years between 2000 and 2020. So, our seed oil consumption doubled.
What happened to our sugar consumption? Well, that actually went down by a good chunk, like, five to 10 per cent, depending on what you consider sugar, whether it’s added sugars or natural sugars. Anyway, sugar went down at that time. What happened to our obesity rates? They practically doubled in that timeframe.
The other thing that’s fascinating about this, what happened to our total calories? Pretty much a flat line, right around 2000, our total calories were something around 2000 calories. Then by 2020, the average person was eating like just maybe 50 calories more. That’s not going to double obesity rates. So, this suggests there’s a correlation here that is strongly suggestive that seed oils may be capable of increasing our weight without increasing our calorie consumption.
Mr. Jekielek:
You’re saying seed oils definitely affect the body in a sense that it doesn’t like to burn the fat that is seed oil-rich, so to speak. So, there’s a causal mechanism that’s there that could be responsible should the right studies be done. And there’s no other factor that you’ve been able to find that could contribute that way. Am I reading you right here?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, absolutely. There are many other changes, many other variables that you could look at. You could look at screen time, at lack of activity, you could look at, you know, even plastics and, you know, endocrine disruptors, you could look at those things. But if you don’t have the same kind of pretty much perfect correlation, or if you still have obesity without those factors, right? Much of the time, then it’s what’s the mechanism, right? Like, how would plastic in our body make us gain weight?
Mr. Jekielek:
Well, let’s talk about the obvious one you just mentioned, right? How has people moving around changed from 2000 to 2020 over that time?
Dr. Shanahan:
It’s changing in a couple of different ways. So we have more people who are doing kind of like more intense fitness, but then we have fewer people engaging in just spontaneous activity because we’re all stuck in front of screens, we have to do less walking, we don’t have to go out and shop anymore, we can do everything online, right? So, that’s a very important variable. You can take a deep dive, you can probe that question.
The way that you can do that is by, well, we have lots of studies on diet. And we, when I look at the dietary studies, there’s something called diet and exercise resistant obesity. And these are people that can’t lose weight with the normal calorie restriction and increase in activity, and nobody can really explain why.
But it could be that something really bad is happening in their body, preventing them from doing anything other than building body fat, like when they exercise, preventing them from building muscle properly when they exercise. So, that’s something that’s not really well understood, that phenomenon, but is a well-recognized phenomenon; diet-resistant obesity.
Mr. Jekielek:
Well, I think you’re making a really compelling case here in terms of, you know, there’s been this massive shift in our diets. And of course, that corresponds to increased, all sorts of increased disease loads and various types of problems and depression and things like that. And for some reason, we just really haven’t studied something that is a very obvious thing that should get a lot of study put into it. I mean, that, I think ultimately, like you’ve done a bunch of remarkable work, but it’s kind of the obvious thing that needs to be looked at. That’s what I’m hearing from you.
Dr. Shanahan:
It is. Yes, it’s the obvious thing that needs to be taken seriously because, honestly, we do have a lot of evidence that these oils do crazy bad things, from animal studies and then just from looking at observational human diet studies across populations, right? So, it’s kind of like we are in the middle of a giant experiment. What kind of experiment?
Well, it’s not randomized or controlled in any way; it’s called an observational experiment. Never before in human history have we eaten so much of these seed oils. And never before in human history have we been fat or had autoimmune disorders, inflammatory disorders, or food allergies at the rates that we do, or developmental neurological disorders in children at the rate that we do. And there is a mechanism linking seed oils to every single one of these things. It has to do with that state of, you know, with what happens when our mitochondria try to burn seed oils, and we get free radicals in our cells, and we get oxidative stress.
These are—I’m using a bunch of complex toxicology terms—but that is the mechanism that medical science could easily investigate to see the validity of this theory. We don’t even need new research; we just need to go back and look at all the data that we’ve got, but isolating out seed oils as an independent variable, which, shockingly, has never been done.
Mr. Jekielek:
When I hear you talking about all these impacts that the seed oils are having on the mitochondria and elsewhere inside the cells, many of them are connected with cancer.
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, absolutely. One of the things that has reemerged, I would have to say, is a hypothesis on the root cause of cancer that came from the early 19th century by a very prominent, brilliant German scientist named Otto Warburg. It’s called the Warburg effect, and he observed that cancer cells had dysfunctional mitochondria and that those dysfunctional mitochondria were going to precede any kind of abnormality in the genetic code, in the DNA. He was thinking cancer begins as a metabolic disease in the mitochondria, not the way medical science is saying that it begins today, which is as one random mutation somewhere in your DNA, and then all of a sudden that cell just divides and then metastasizes throughout your body, and it’s like you’re doomed.
That is not the vision of cancer that the best scientists are converging on today. Probably, you’ve either had Thomas Seyfried on or will have him on soon. Thomas Seyfried is one of the leading advocates for cancer as a metabolic disease, published a giant book by that name, and is making a fantastic argument. I discussed his work in the context of seed oils.
One thing Dr. Thomas Seyfried didn’t know, I interviewed him for my book, he did not know that seed oils can be mitochondrially toxic. He didn’t know that. That means if what I’m saying is true, seed oils are toxic to your mitochondria. And if you avoid seed oils, your mitochondria are much better, much healthier.
Cancer starts in the mitochondria, and if you keep your mitochondria healthy, you have a very low risk of cancer. If those two things are true, then it means that the best way to treat cancer is before it even starts. Don’t breed it. Don’t harm your mitochondria. If you have cancer in your family history at all, then avoiding seed oils is probably the best way for you to avoid cancer.
One of the things that Dr. Seyfried is doing is treating cancer with the keto diet once it develops. I think that’s brilliant and fantastic. But before cancer develops, there’s no reason to believe we need a keto diet to keep our mitochondria healthy. We just need a diet that doesn’t poison our mitochondria.
Mr. Jekielek:
But, in effect, a keto diet is something that I’ve done at different times in my life, and I find it’s one of the few things that actually works for me, if you will, right? The thing that struck me about the keto diet is simply that it prevents you from eating all sorts of things that will make you fat. Well, I mean, aside from being keto, you know, aside from burning fat instead of carbohydrates and activating the ketogenic process and all that, you dramatically reduce the amount of ultra-processed food in your diet the moment you go on a keto diet. That was my kind of revelation some years after doing it for a while.
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, so let’s talk about an experiment in rats where they gave them a keto diet. A keto diet is a very low-carbohydrate diet, doesn’t have a lot of sugar, very low starch content, but lots of fat. In this particular study on mice, the fat was like corn oil or soy oil. It wasn’t butter. It wasn’t tallow. The rats or mice had tons of ketones in their bloodstream, because seed oils don’t stop you from making ketones. But seed oils promote inflammation.
So these poor mice, they had fatty liver, they were starting to become diabetic, they had all kinds of inflammatory fat; their fat was unhealthy. They had very poor exercise tolerance because possibly their muscles were not being fueled properly because of what has to happen when you are burning some of those polyunsaturates. Your cells may shut down their energy production and may need to rely more on sugar. You’re going to become hypoglycemic. You run out of energy quicker on a keto diet that’s high in seed oils.
In the year 2012, Mark Sisson published a book called The Primal Blueprint, and it was the second edition of that book. In that book, they interviewed me for four or five pages worth of content. And I said, don’t eat seed oils. So, the paleo diet became seed oil-free, thanks largely to Mark Sisson’s humongous influence and the fact that they interviewed me a little bit for the book.
Then the same thing started happening with the paleo diet because, again, Mark Sisson, they interviewed me again to talk about their keto reset diet, which came out in 2017. Same deal. You’ve got to avoid seed oils. You’ve got to avoid them. So, eat these other healthy traditional fats. That was the first keto diet in 30 years to become such a blockbuster, and I think the reason is because it was more effective.
The history of the keto diet really begins in the 1970s.The keto diet for weight loss begins in the 1970s when a Dr. Atkins discovered that a high-fat diet made your body produce ketones, and ketones suppressed your appetite and made you feel like you were full of energy. And back in the 70s, we had about one-third of the problem with seed oils as we do now, so you didn’t have to know much about them.
He recommended cream, and at the beginning, he didn’t have books. He wasn’t providing recipes. But then as he got more popular, he provided recipes that included a lot of seed oils. The books became less effective. The diet became less effective. A lot of people would say they would go on the keto diet, they would get the low-carb flu. It wasn’t working for them.
The diet almost died. The keto diet, Atkins diet, was pretty much dead in 2010 when I went to an obesity conference. Pretty much nobody was really talking about it. They were still talking about the benefits of ketones and trying to publish books. But until the books were specifically focused on avoiding seed oils, people did not seem to see the benefits. So that’s my take on some of that recent history of what’s gone on with this popular diet.
Mr. Jekielek:
I mean, isn’t it astonishing that in my childhood, we were told again and again that margarine was better than butter, right? And we used it. And I mean, the thing is, my mother was deeply committed to butter. So, like, we actually always had it and we used it. But we all, presumably because of the intense social pressure to use margarine, right? We also had margarine. I remember it very distinctly that we always had both. But it was a thing. You talked about it. It was in the kind of conversation, popular consciousness, if you will, right?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, absolutely. Margarine is now no longer made the way it was in the 1970s because we came to understand, soon after running the experiment on the human race, that the trans fats in the margarine that were put there on purpose. It was made of canola oil and cottonseed oil. So, it was made out of these oils by a process that changed the chemistry. There were no longer these polyunsaturates that oxidize easily. Instead, there were trans fats that have this nice texture that’s spreadable. So, we were able to identify those trans fats as problematic pretty quickly.
By the year 2004, the European Union started to ban them, they reduced them from the food supply, and we don’t have hydrogenated oils to any degree in the food supply in the entire world anymore. Margarine was less problematic and less toxic than the seed oils because the chemistry was much more stable. So, as bad as it was and as good as it has been to get them out, what happened afterwards was really tragic because we didn’t know what to replace them with.
So, let’s go back to what I talked about earlier with our calories didn’t go up between the year 2000 and 2020. I said our seed oil consumption pretty much doubled. Why did it double in that particular timeframe? Here’s why—it was because of this trans fat ban. We had been getting a ton of calories from hydrogenated oils. When they became illegal, we put liquid oils in these deep fat fryers instead, right? We got them out of margarines, and so now margarine is made with a mixture of palm oil and seed oil to get the same texture.
But what’s happening in the fryers is a little more invisible because we don’t see what goes on in the restaurant kitchen. They just took out the trans fat, the big blocks of hydrogenated shortening they used to fry all of our food in, and dumped in liquid seed oils, which become some of the most toxic things that you could possibly eat when you heat them for days or weeks at a time.
So, we’ve made our food supply far more toxic by getting rid of a man-made fat that we thought was doing harm and was doing harm. We thought though that we were fixing the problem, but because we didn’t understand the chemistry. By we, I mean medical doctors and public health authorities. They actually made the problem significantly worse. And I think there’s a lot of reasons why we’re less healthy, more mentally ill, and bigger and fatter nowadays.
Mr. Jekielek:
You could very easily imagine that by removing, by this ban on trans fats, you’ve kind of removed the unhealthy element. Oh, we’ve solved that now, right?
Dr. Shanahan:
So, there’s so much mythology around this, and so many people are at different stages of understanding the history of what happened. I don’t actually hear that we’ve solved the seed oil problem. What I do hear, really from health professionals, is generally just a complete blankness when I talk about seed oils. It doesn’t register because their ideology is that saturated fat is what’s problematic, and they don’t know what seed oils are. They don’t learn about them.
Now that I’ve been talking about them for, you know, six, 10, 20 years, medical doctors are kind of getting to the idea that, oh, well, there’s this trend of wellness influencers claiming fear-mongering around seed oils, and there’s no science behind it. So that’s one of the common responses that I get. It’s a little bit hard to break through when you’ve emotionally already kind of settled on an answer, right? Like, you haven’t really engaged with the data.
But you have seen a lot of social media people just talking about seed oils, and they don’t really seem like they would know more chemistry than the cardiologist I consult with who says saturated fats are bad and the opposite, so I’m just going to ignore that, right? And so, creating a paradigm shift in science from basically my living room is quite challenging.
Mr. Jekielek:
Yes, well, no, so this is what I was thinking; that you could just say, wait, we have this problem with fats, and now we’ve solved this problem with fats. Let’s move on, right? Except that you’ve identified a very different problem with fats that I guess you’re saying too few people have an awareness of even now. I mean, to be perfectly honest, until recently, I was completely unaware of this until the last few years.
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, pretty much until RFK [Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.], somebody running for president and now working in the administration started talking about it. Most people would have no clue when you brought up the term seed oil. Even previously, for 15 years, I was just calling them vegetable oils. That’s the industry term. That’s what you see on a label when you’re looking for bad ingredients.
I mentioned the Hateful Eight will also be aware of the word vegetable oil, right? When you’re buying a bottle of oil, if it says vegetable oil, you’ve got to turn it around and see if it is soy, corn, or canola. It’s not going to be olive oil. So, it’s pretty much equivalent to seed oil, even though vegetable oil would technically include healthy oils like coconut and olive.
So, the conversation is just so bungled in so many ways. We don’t even have the right terminology, right? Why would the industry create a term to identify oils that are the cheapest, that it likes to use, that may not be the best for us? Why would it create the term? Medical science doesn’t understand the chemistry, so why would they create the term? Well, they didn’t.
That’s why I created a term because I just wanted a simple way to refer to the fact that not all seed oils are toxic; there are only eight of them. And the reason I picked those eight is because of how they are grown, how they are processed, how they have not been selected for fattiness for as many years as seed oils that are not problematic, like sesame oil, right? With thousands of years of human cultivation of sesame oil, making it safe.
There are really just so many barriers to the full understanding of the truth, because every step of the way, somebody has come in to make it confusing, whether it’s the American Heart Association or some of these other wellness influencers who are just talking about all seed oils are unhealthy, or all polyunsaturated fatty acids, all linoleic acid is unhealthy. So there are so many steps of the way where confusion comes in, that the conversation, I have no way to really maintain control over the conversation since I’m not at HHS [U.S. Dept. of Health & Human Services].
I’ve just been doing my best by going onto podcasts like this and trying to help write books and get people to sit down and concentrate and really understand the big picture because it can’t happen in a sound bite. Unfortunately, most media, unlike you, Jan, it’s about sound bites. It’s about just giving me the 30-second headline, true today, disproven tomorrow, kind of thing. And that’s where we are.
With nutrition science, it just seems like a bunch of noise to a lot of people. But actually nutrition science, when done carefully and looked at properly, is an incredibly helpful, useful, and empowering science that people have come to understand enables them to have seemingly miraculous recoveries of serious medical problems.
Mr. Jekielek:
So let’s talk about this, okay? Because let’s say you’re a mom and you have, you know, many small children, maybe even big children, and you realize that seed oils have been a significant part of their diet. You’re basically saying that small children’s brains, especially over the last 20 years, have been built on these oils. They’re in the fat situation. Maybe people are watching their kids or themselves have this inability to get leaner even though they’re exercising. They’re apparently doing all the right things. Is there hope for us, Dr. Cate?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, there absolutely is hope. It’s kind of like a plant that you went on vacation, you neglected it, it didn’t get enough light or water, it’s all wilted, leaves are turning brown. Nurture that plant, and it will come back to health. You can nurture and nourish your body, dysfunctional cells, struggling brain cells that are having a hard time learning, making connections. Once they are made out of the right stuff, they will develop the right behaviors, new connections, and you can heal. This is how I’ve seen some of these amazing, miraculous recoveries.
Here’s a kind of a crazy but fascinating example. When I worked in Napa Valley, California, I had a practice there and my nurse roomed this one patient, and under the chief complaint, which is why she was there, it was allergic to water. You know, we need water to live, right? We have water in our bodies.
Mr. Jekielek:
Like, this was actual. She’s allergic to water?
Dr. Shanahan:
That was written on the page, so that was my question. She said that it took her so long to just do the simple act that we take for granted of being able to take a shower. She could only do it like once or twice a week because it was so painful, itchy; her skin would burn when on contact with water. It would take her like four to six hours to just get through it. She was like, so anyway, I’m looking for a new doctor, maybe somebody who can help me.
I said, I don’t know if avoiding seed oils and following what I call the four pillars of a human diet, which is what I talk about in my first book, Deep Nutrition, will help. But I know that it’s not going to hurt, and maybe it'll have the side effect of helping somehow. She was French, and I know that you can like cheese and foie gras in Napa Valley. It wasn’t hard to find people there who were foodies, and you’re going to like what you get to eat.
That was our conversation. She was very enthused, very excited. She bought a copy of the book right there, and I didn’t see her again for a long time. And I thought, I wonder whatever happened to her. I don’t know. And one day, about six months later, she’s there, she is in my room. When I opened the door, she couldn’t contain herself. She jumped off the exam table and had the book with her, dog-eared, and underlined.
She said, thank you. Nothing else has helped. But this is making such a difference. She wasn’t all better, but she was down to half-an-hour for a shower, and she could do it multiple times a week. She could easily wash her hands, just the simple act of washing her hands. She was so much better, and that was just six months in.
Then I ran into her at a restaurant a couple years later, and she was even better than that. Like she was almost normal, she felt. She had converted everybody at the Silverado Resort, a golf resort there, and they were all big fans of the book. They’re trying to get the chef to avoid seed oils and it became a miniature movement thanks to her really life-changing recovery.
Mr. Jekielek:
So, what are the four pillars? Huge suspense you’ve built here.
Dr. Shanahan:
If you want to know all about them, read Deep Nutrition. They’re called the Four Pillars of the Human Diet, because I studied over 100 cultures around the entire world that had a track record of success, like having healthy children for multiple generations, and found that there were four things that they all did in common. That’s why I call them the four pillars of a human diet.
Very simply, it is getting fresh food as nature made it, and fermenting and sprouting your food, which is working with nature to either preserve or enhance the nutrition. The third pillar is meat on the bone, by which I mean really just using the connective tissue to make bone broth, and you extract this stuff called proteoglycans, which is good for your connective tissue.
It’s a missing food group from the American food supply. It is neither protein nor sugar. It’s glycoprotein, proteoglycan, it’s a whole family. So those are all missing. You get them when you save the bones and make bone stock.
The third is organ meats like liver. At one time, people used to eat nose-to-tail. We used to honor the animal. We used to enjoy eating liver. When I was in Hawaii, there were so many people who were very close to the tradition of the Filipino cooking tradition, and I wrote Deep Nutrition while I was living in Hawaii.
So I really had this window into the health benefits of eating this way because so many of my patients were eating this way and grew up eating this way, and now were in their 50s, 60s, 70s, and 80s and were flourishing. They were just remarkably healthy. It was a reality check when I 10 years later moved back to New Hampshire, where I saw what aging was like.
Mr. Jekielek:
Fascinating. So, okay, let me see if I got this right. Fruit and vegetables, sauerkraut, bone marrow, and heart and liver. If I eat that, I’m great.
Dr. Shanahan:
All right, let’s reframe this a little bit. So, yes, fruit and vegetables. But those aren’t the only things people ate raw. They would eat steak tartare, they would eat raw egg yolks, they would eat sushi, that kind of thing. They would eat milk raw. Milk was not pasteurized. If we wanted to, we could broaden our horizons about what fresh food is.
The second one is sauerkraut. Yes, 100 per cent. That’s perfect. Sprouted grain bread. Yes, absolutely. But the third one is not bone marrow. I’m glad you said that, because a lot of people also make that leap. It’s really the joint material, that shiny white stuff at the end of the bones. That is cartilage, the wiggly, white, wormy stuff that is tendons and ligaments. I’m not really selling it.
Mr. Jekielek:
But I don’t really like to crunch, yes.
Dr. Shanahan:
Well, you won’t because the way that people extracted nutrition from them was by boiling them, using them in soups and stews until they dissolved, or just making bone broth. So, that’s really the third pillar. I should have just called it bone broth. You have the right idea about the organ meats like liver, but technically, bone marrow is actually an organ meat.
Mr. Jekielek:
Ah, I just went heavy on the organ meats here. That’s what happened and missed the connective tissue. So, basically, what you’re saying, if I’m understanding you correctly, is you go to, but there’s also muscle meats, right? Obviously, steak is a very popular food item in America, right? Probably you would be pro-steak.
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes. The third pillar is meat on the bone, so absolutely, meat. But right now we just mostly eat just the meat and throw everything else out.
Mr. Jekielek:
What, why the organ meats?
Dr. Shanahan:
Organ meats are repositories of different nutrients in an animal’s body. So, if you think of the spectrum of nutrients that we need that are in our bodies and that are in our animal friends’ bodies—friends that we have to eat—as a rainbow, then you could say muscle meat is maybe like the color blue, or maybe it should be the color maroon, so it’s more intuitive. But each organ kind of specializes in having a different nutritional profile.
So, the liver has a lot of B vitamins, has some vitamin K, and it’s got some of the fat-soluble vitamins. Some of the bone marrow actually has special fatty acids that may, in fact, be like vitamins, and we may all be missing these special fatty acids with unknown effects, like the intestines, those are great sources. People used to make sausage using intestines, right? And they would just eat the intestine too, right? And so that is another source of cartilage or that meat-on-the-bone kind of action there where you get the support for our cartilage tissues.
Cartilage is not made out of protein or carbohydrate; it’s made out of that blend of intramolecular blend of a sugar molecule alternating with a protein molecule and different patterns of this. That’s what makes this very strong fascia and ligamentous tissue. And when we’re not eating that, but we are, you know, eating plenty of protein and building our muscle and exercising our muscle, but we’re not building or eating the raw materials to make our ligaments that connect our muscle to our bone equally strong, we see a lot of overuse injuries.
And this was a big thing I brought to the Lakers when I was working on their staff for six years, where we completely changed their diet, and they loved the bone broths.But they didn’t love the organ meat so much. I think the closest thing that they could do was egg yolks. Actually, egg yolks have a similar-ish nutrition profile in many ways, to organ meats, because they’re very high in cholesterol and some of the fat-soluble vitamins that we need, eggs being the precursor food for an entire organism. So, there’s a lot of nutrition in the yolk.
Mr. Jekielek:
So, wait, you’re telling me the LA Lakers are using your type of diet?
Dr. Shanahan:
Yes, they were. So, for six years or more, they brought me on, and I revised their diet. Then it was the person who brought me on, the head trainer, Gary Vitti. Then he retired, and the whole training staff and the management turned over. So, the nutritional philosophy turned over, just as a byproduct. People like to hire their friends, so they had a lot of friends they hired to be dieticians instead of me, and they just changed everything.
Unfortunately, the chef was really the gem, the cornerstone of the whole thing, because she could make these foods in ways that players loved their vegetables, which is quite a thing. Her name was Sandra Padilla. Now, she’s a private chef for the A-listers in Hollywood, and she’s keeping them healthy. She was cooking for LeBron James. As LeBron James became a Laker, he improved his diet. He attributes his longevity there to his diet, which is the same thing that the Lakers were eating.
Mr. Jekielek:
What is the most common pushback you get when you insist that reducing seed oils from a diet is critical to health? What is the hardest thing for you to respond to?
Dr. Shanahan:
The hardest thing for me to respond to is when people accuse me of being like a grifter, like somehow telling people the truth about seed oils or what I see as the truth about seed oils is making me rich. Yes, I have books, but if anybody’s written a book, it’s very hard to get rich off of a book. For the time that it takes, you can be doing a lot of other things that make you rich faster. That’s like, that’s the most upsetting because it’s like, I’m the opposite of a grifter. So, that one I’m sort of at a loss for words.
But the most common refrain from interested experts—people who really do care, you know, who believe that the politically correct Mediterranean diet is healthy—maybe they, you know, maybe they’re dieticians, maybe they are high up in the Adventist hospital system, which really controls a lot of the nutrition conversation because they’re Seventh-day Adventists and they’re semi-vegetarian.
But the most common refrain is, oh, that’s just a correlation, and when people feel better when they stop eating seed oils, it’s because they stop eating junk food and processed food, and that’s what’s really harmful. And my response to that is, if they were ever to talk directly to me, which they don’t, they haven’t yet, is, all right, then what is it that makes processed food so harmful exactly?
My point is that seed oils put the junk in junk food. There are foods that we know are junk food, and nutrition science has done a very poor job of identifying why they are bad. I put this question to a room full of doctors when I went to a conference recently. I said, we all know processed food is unhealthy. Oh, I said junk food. What makes junk food junk? And they all had different answers.
There were things like salt or it has too many ingredients or it has preservatives or artificial colorings. I said, okay, all right then. Why is a bag of low-sodium potato chips? Is that junk food, or would you consider that a healthy food? They said, no, of course it’s junk food. And I asked, why?
They said, well, because it’s in a package. So, why is the broccoli that you buy in a package healthy? I could go on like this all day. They have no clue. They have not used any kind of logical algorithm to decide what food is good and what food is bad. It’s just what they believe.
Mr. Jekielek:
Well, Cate, so you’re setting up the big question, right? That I’ve been thinking about this whole interview, okay, right? Are beef tallow fries, deep-fried beef tallow fries—and I’m not talking about the ones that have been pre-fried with vegetable oils, but actually fully deep-fried in beef tallow fries—are they healthy?
Dr. Shanahan:
Well, if you got it on the first use of that fresh tallow, they’re as healthy as you could get, right? Like, I’m not going to say it’s a health food, because potatoes are not the healthiest vegetable out there, but they’re not toxic. And hey, that’s a great step up from, you know, at least as bad as a pack of french fries. So, there’s another side to this, which we haven’t touched on, but just like fried food generally is not the healthy way to make food, especially not today. Do you want to talk about the story of a frozen pizza?
Mr. Jekielek:
Yes, tell me about the frozen pizza. Let’s hear the story.
Dr. Shanahan:
Here’s what happens. Your frozen pizza that you buy is made. Let’s start by focusing on the oil that goes into the sauce. First, it’s made not with olive oil anymore, but soy or one of these blends of soy and canola or whatever. One of these hateful oils. So, that has been heated and contains a small amount of these toxic aldehydes already as it leaves the factory and as it enters the next factory, which is going to turn it into marinara sauce, where it is heated again to make marinara sauce for the pizza. And when you heat it, you rapidly accelerate toxin formation because you’re stirring in oxygen, and the heat accelerates those reactions, so you get more toxin forming.
Okay, so now you’ve made your marinara sauce. It’s sitting in a jar somewhere, probably exposed to light. Small amounts of toxins are forming because of that. The oxygen in there is still reacting. Toxins are forming at a faster rate than they were on the previous trip.
But now they’re on another trip. They’re on a trip to the pizza factory where they’re going to be spread on pizza dough and baked in a pizza oven. Again, it is possibly heated to 500 degrees and more toxins will form, because of lots of air and surface area. Toxins will form very quickly.
Okay, so now we have more toxins than we did before, and it’s going to take another trip. It’s going to go to the restaurant or the grocery store where it’s going to be frozen until it gets microwaved. So, in all that time, toxins are still forming. Maybe the freezing slows them down. We don’t know. But we know that when you heat it again, more toxins are going to form. Maybe microwaves make them form even faster because it’s some kind of radiation. We don’t know. A study has never been done.
But by the time you eat that pizza, it is so full of toxins. I cannot eat previously frozen, microwaved pizzas. I cannot even take one bite because once you’ve gotten these seed oils out of your diet, all the protective hardening of your stomach lining that you had developed, which is not good and can lead to cancer, has gone away, and now you have normal, healthy stomach lining. Well, it’s very sensitive.
I took a bite of one of these pizzas when I came in late to the hotel. I said, oh, I'll try the pizza. Within seconds, I was hearing burbling sounds, the heartburn sounds coming up from my stomach. That’s a sign that the stuff is pretty darn toxic. Have studies ever been done on pizza marinara sauce? No, that is very difficult to do. But this is the kind of thing that nobody is talking about.
In this conversation on ultra-processed food, I have not heard anybody say how many times the food is heated. I have not heard anybody say, is it seed oil or olive oil in there? And you know what? The most commonly used, all these academics using the term ultra-processed food, saying we got to stay away from ultra-processed food, are clueless about what seed oils are. The category that they put seed oils in is called the NOVA classification system, which grades these oils and all foods on how processed they’ve been.
So, the best is grade one, and the worst is grade five, ultra-processed. Grade one is like your fruits and vegetables, fresh food. Grade two is where they put seed oils next to virgin olive oil, butter, tallow, even though refined seed oils are literally the most processed food in the entire food supply. That’s just how clueless our academics are, and they think they know it all.
So, that’s a problem. There is this saying that I can never get right. I think it was Mark Twain who said, never let your education get in the way of your learning. Our dietitians and nutritionists are doing just that.
Mr. Jekielek:
Basically, you’re saying coconut oil, sesame oil, which of course has a strong taste, tallow, olive oil, and coconut, all these things don’t degrade nearly as much when they’re deep-fried or fried or whatever, as the seed oils do. But there are still some problems, and you shouldn’t just be deep-frying everything.
Dr. Shanahan:
Let’s use the word heating instead of frying or deep-frying. And so you shouldn’t be injudicious with heat. Don’t burn your food. But we kind of burn our oils because we repeatedly heat them. Why deep-frying is particularly, or deep-fried food is particularly toxic, is because these days we use that oil for days and days, sometimes weeks, depending on the restaurant. That’s extreme exposure to heat. So, it’s about how we cook it. And we really, this is another part of the nutritional conversation; how did you cook your food? That just isn’t happening.
I have another book we haven’t talked about called Food Rules, where I talk about some of the rules of cooking. One of them is, be gentle with your food. For example, the healthiest way to cook your eggs is to poach them, to leave the yolk runny, but cook the white part.
How are we cooking our food? It changes the nutritional value. Fried food is one of the fastest ways to deteriorate seed oils. So, that’s why a lot of our junk foods or things that we know intuitively are probably unhealthy are fried in seed oils.
Now, you can use tallow and fry it, and it will be just fine, but you can’t use it again and again. On the one hand, these restaurants that are using tallow in their deep-fat fryer, and that’s good. They’re investing more money, but then are they using the oil longer? Because by the end, that is just as bad, and no one’s talking about that either.
Mr. Jekielek:
Basically, you’re saying if tallow came into use as seed oils are in use, it would also have toxic things in it, just not as quickly.
Dr. Shanahan:
That’s exactly right. So it’s the dose that makes the poison. You can abuse and toxify anything; you can burn anything if you add enough heat, right? But it’s much, much harder to do that with tallow. So if you’re reasonable about it and you change it, like, if you’re at home and you want to deep-fry good quality food, you don’t have to worry about restaurant deep-fried food. You get your own deep fryer if you love fried food. And get tallow and use it three times. That is not going to be toxic.
Let’s talk about the frying pan. Most of the frying that we do is on the stovetop. What’s the difference between frying and sautéing? Most people don’t know the difference. There’s not much of a difference. Sautéing is a little faster. You can thermally stress and abuse an oil during any one of these processes; it depends on a lot of variables.
It is very important when you’re doing pan-frying and oil frying at home, even if you’re not deep-frying, to use the healthier fats. It makes a bigger difference there because you’re only using them once. You’re going to come off with a food that has zero heat-generated toxin, vs. if you use canola oil to do whatever they call it—chicken-fried steak or steak-fried chicken.
If you use canola oil, you can generate as much aldehyde toxicity in a half an hour cooking on a stovetop because of all the surface area and the bubbling as you can in a deep fryer after six to 12 hours of continuous use at a higher temperature, you see. So, it’s the heat, the heat exposure. Think of it like a sunburn. It’s time and temperature.
Mr. Jekielek:
But basically, first of all, the seed oils are themselves already heated a lot and highly processed in the first place, still much better than reheated. But then tallow, olive oil, coconut oil, sesame oil, and maybe some others that we haven’t talked about yet, will not have nearly that bad an effect, basically.
Dr. Shanahan:
Absolutely. What you just described is basically what’s missing from this conversation: the gradations. That’s what makes this kind of toxicity difficult because in a sunflower seed that you just picked from the farm, there’s no toxicity. But in sunflower seed oil, that’s the marinara sauce on a pizza, there could be a lot of toxicity. And depending on what you do, you can make or avoid toxicity.
Mr. Jekielek:
And we don’t necessarily measure it at the right moments, or the manufacturer, or the FDA [U.S. Food & Drug Administration], or whoever is not measuring it at the right moments to determine that the right way. Is that right?
Dr. Shanahan:
That’s correct. And generally, they are just plain old not measuring it because this is called a process contaminant, the aldehydes that form during the processing or the process of cooking. It’s called a process contaminant. That’s not something that is regulated, period. It is not regulated.
Mr. Jekielek:
Got it. So, a final question for me here is, I’m someone who travels a lot, is on the move a lot, and has to eat out a lot, in effect. What is your recommendation for someone like me to reduce seed oils the most?
Dr. Shanahan:
Okay, well, the first thing is to decide that you want to do it because then it becomes just a matter of logistics.But there are quite a few logistics and there are a lot of strategies. One of the most important is if you go to a restaurant, use this line. Do you have anything back there in the kitchen that you can cook for me from scratch right now in butter or virgin olive oil, not an oil blend? So it took me about 20 years to come up with that, you know, very short line.
Mr. Jekielek:
Genius.
Dr. Shanahan:
I spent a lot of years asking questions, and they never knew the answer. By the time they would come out with the information, they were frustrated, and everybody was tired of the whole process. That’s what you ask. Just tell them what to look for.
Mr. Jekielek:
Oh, well, that is an incredible rule of thumb. Okay, as we finish, is there anything else you'd like to tell me as we finish up?
Dr. Shanahan:
If this information is interesting to you, if you believe science is more than just black and white, if there’s nuance, if you believe that nature is intelligent and that scientists ought to respect that, I think you'll like my content. So, please come to my website, which is drkate.com.
Mr. Jekielek:
Well, Dr. Cate Shanahan, it’s such a pleasure to have had you on.
Dr. Shanahan:
It’s a great pleasure to meet with you, and I loved your questions.
This interview has been partially edited for clarity and brevity.














