Is Perfectionism a Symptom of Underlying Illness?
Comments
Link successfully copied
(Peter Cade/Getty Images)
By Jingduan Yang
10/31/2024Updated: 11/10/2024

As a physician with extensive experience in integrative medicine and mental health, I’ve worked with numerous patients who would be considered overachievers. They are often successful professionals, driven by a relentless desire to succeed and excel in their fields. Yet behind the façade of accomplishment lies a significant cost to their physical, mental, and biochemical well-being. Over the years, I’ve observed how the traits that propel these people to greatness also become their most significant health risks.

Perfectionism and Overachieving

One of the most striking traits I see in overachievers is perfectionism. These individuals set unrealistically high standards for themselves and often cannot rest until every task is completed flawlessly.

Unfortunately, perfectionism is not just about being meticulous, but also about being relentlessly critical of oneself. Many of my patients suffer from chronic anxiety, constantly fearing that any mistake will lead to failure. This mindset traps them in a loop of stress, worry, and dissatisfaction, regardless of how much they achieve.

Many overachievers equate their self-worth with productivity. They become trapped in a cycle of overworking, often sacrificing their health and personal lives to meet professional goals. Compulsive work behaviors—such as never turning off their phones, skipping meals, and forgoing sleep—are common. Over time, I’ve seen this lead to chronic fatigue, adrenal exhaustion, and even burnout.

Factors That Affect Overachievers

In my experience, overachievers often have a combination of underlying factors driving their behaviors: undermethylation, pyrrole disorder, or a personality disorder.

1. Undermethylation

A patient I recently treated, a 42-year-old corporate executive, came to me after experiencing debilitating anxiety and insomnia for years. Her perfectionism drove her to work 60 or more hours a week, with constant self-imposed deadlines. Despite earning a top-tier salary and multiple promotions, she remained deeply anxious, continually fearing that she hadn’t done enough.

She developed chronic tension headaches and gastrointestinal distress due to ongoing stress. Integrating cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) with biochemical testing revealed she was undermethylated, which compounded her stress response.

Methylation is a critical biochemical process that regulates many functions, including DNA repair, detoxification, neurotransmitter function, and mental health. Undermethylation leads to low levels of key neurotransmitters such as serotonin and dopamine, which are critical for mood regulation. Patients with undermethylation often exhibit traits such as perfectionism, obsessive-compulsive behavior, and high levels of anxiety.

Tests for Methylation

The following are ways to test methylation:

  • Whole Blood Histamine Test: This blood test measures histamine levels and helps determine methylation status. Elevated histamine often indicates undermethylation, while low histamine suggests overmethylation.
  • Serum Homocysteine Test: Homocysteine levels offer insight into the body’s methylation cycle. Elevated levels are often seen in people with poor methylation function and can increase the risk of cardiovascular disease.
  • DNA Methylation Testing: Advances in testing allow for more direct assessments of methylation patterns through DNA-based tests, which analyze genes involved in the methylation process (such as MTHFR, COMT, and CBS genes). These tests typically involve a saliva or blood sample.
In the case of the 42-year-old woman experiencing chronic anxiety and insomnia, we treated her with a combination of stress management techniques, nutritional support to correct her methylation imbalance, and acupuncture for symptom relief. After that, she reported significant improvements in anxiety and sleep.

Over the following weeks, her symptoms lessened, allowing her to cut down on medication use. Stress management techniques such as mindfulness and breathing exercises helped control acute anxiety, while nutritional support corrected her methylation imbalance. Acupuncture provided her immediate relief, reducing physical stress symptoms such as tension headaches. Her mood improved, and she adopted a healthier lifestyle, supporting long-term recovery.

2. Pyrrole Disorder

I recall a 35-year-old woman who struggled with anxiety, irritability, and fatigue for years despite trying various treatments. I examined her, and it turned out that she had pyrrole disorder.

Also known as kryptopyrroluria, pyrrole disorder is another biochemical imbalance commonly found in overachievers. This condition involves excessive excretion of kryptopyrroles—a byproduct of hemoglobin synthesis—that bind with zinc and vitamin B6, leading to deficiencies of these essential nutrients. Pyrrole disorder is associated with anxiety, irritability, and mood swings, which can worsen overachievement tendencies.

Tests for Pyrrole Disorder

Testing for pyrrole disorder involves a simple urine test that measures the concentration of kryptopyrroles. Because kryptopyrroles are sensitive to light and heat, the sample must be handled carefully; kept in a dark, amber-colored vial; wrapped in foil; and frozen until it reaches the lab.

Treatment for this disorder typically involves high-dose zinc and vitamin B6 (in its active form, P5P) to correct deficiencies and improve mood stability. Patients may also benefit from magnesium and omega-3 fatty acids to reduce inflammation and support mental health.

We tailored the young woman’s treatment to include nutrient supplementation, specifically zinc and B6. The results were remarkable; her anxiety eased, and her energy levels returned. This case highlighted how addressing an underlying biochemical imbalance can significantly improve quality of life.

3. Personality Disorders

Certain personality disorders can also influence an overachiever’s health risks. For example, people with obsessive-compulsive disorder may exhibit excessive perfectionism, orderliness, and need for control, all of which can contribute to chronic stress and burnout.

Similarly, those with narcissistic personality disorder may push themselves to succeed to maintain their self-image but struggle with feelings of inadequacy when faced with failure.

Patients with borderline personality disorder, which is characterized by emotional instability, may also exhibit overachievement tendencies to cope with feelings of insecurity.

Long-Term Health Consequences

The combination of psychological, behavioral, social, and biochemical factors can have severe long-term effects on an overachiever’s health. The following are consequences that may develop due to an overachieving lifestyle or personality:
  • Mental Health Disorders: Prolonged stress, perfectionism, and biochemical imbalances increase the risk of anxiety disorders, depression, and burnout. Chronic stress alters brain structure and function, particularly in regions involved in mood regulation.
  • Cardiovascular Risks: Chronic stress and high cortisol levels can lead to hypertension, heart disease, and stroke. Overachievers, particularly those with Type A personality traits, are more vulnerable to cardiovascular issues due to prolonged activation of the body’s stress response.
  • Gastrointestinal Issues: The gut-brain connection is well-documented, and chronic stress can lead to gastrointestinal problems such as irritable bowel syndrome , acid reflux, and ulcers. Emerging research shows that the gut microbiota play a crucial role in mental health, making stress reduction and gut health essential for mental stability.
  • Loneliness and Mortality Risks: Overachievers often sacrifice personal relationships for career success, leading to isolation and loneliness. Research shows that chronic social isolation increases the risk of early mortality and worsens both mental and physical health.

A Holistic Approach to Healing

Overachievers face unique health risks due to their psychological traits, behavioral tendencies, social isolation, and biochemical imbalances. My approach to treating these patients integrates both conventional and integrative medicine to address the root causes of their distress.

Psychological Interventions

CBT, mindfulness techniques, and lifestyle changes are essential to help overachievers manage their perfectionism, anxiety, and stress. Psychological assessments such as the personality assessment inventory, Beck depression inventory, and Beck anxiety inventory guide this therapeutic process.

Nutritional and Biochemical Support

Correcting methylation imbalances and addressing nutrient deficiencies through Walsh Protocol panel testing, including the whole blood histamine test, copper-zinc ratio, and kryptopyrrole test, can significantly improve mood, cognitive function, and overall well-being. Targeted supplementation with methylfolate, B6, zinc, magnesium, and other essential nutrients helps restore biochemical balance.

Acupuncture

Acupuncture can effectively mitigate the health risks commonly faced by overachievers. Here’s how:
  • Stress and Anxiety Relief: Acupuncture promotes relaxation by regulating the nervous system and releasing endorphins, which help lower cortisol levels and reduce stress and anxiety.
  • Improved Sleep Quality: Overachievers often experience insomnia due to overactive minds. Acupuncture balances the body’s energy (qi), improving sleep quality and addressing the root causes of insomnia.
  • Immune Boost: Chronic stress weakens the immune system. Acupuncture enhances immune function by balancing internal systems, increasing resilience to illness.
  • Improved Digestive Health: Stress and irregular eating habits can lead to digestive issues. Acupuncture supports digestion by stimulating key points that harmonize the gut-brain connection.
  • Improved Mental Clarity and Focus: Acupuncture reduces stress and regulates hormones, improving mental clarity and helping overachievers maintain high performance without burning out.

Restoring Work-Life Balance

Encouraging social connections, proper sleep, exercise, and stress-reduction techniques can prevent long-term burnout and improve mental and physical health.

In my clinical experience, a personalized and holistic approach is critical to helping overachievers, especially those with biochemical imbalances, achieve their goals while maintaining their health and well-being in the long term.

Insurance coverage for specialty tests and treatments can vary significantly depending on the patient’s plan and medical condition. Discussing these options with your health care provider and checking with your insurance company to understand potential coverage and costs is essential.

Share This Article:
Dr. Jingduan Yang, FAPA, is a board-certified psychiatrist specializing in integrative and traditional Chinese medicine for chronic mental, behavioral, and physical illnesses. Dr. Yang is also the founder and medical director of the Yang Institute of Integrative Medicine and the American Institute of Clinical Acupuncture and the CEO of Northern Medical Center in New York state. He contributed to the books "Integrative Psychiatry," "Medicine Matters," and "Integrative Therapies for Cancer." He also co-authored "Facing East: Ancient Secrets for Beauty+Health for Modern Age" by HarperCollins and "Clinical Acupuncture and Ancient Chinese Medicine" by Oxford Press.

©2023-2024 California Insider All Rights Reserved. California Insider is a part of Epoch Media Group.